Posted by sarahb on April 7th, 2010 | Comments Off
So it’s been a looong time since we updated this site. It’s our hope to get a little better at keeping you all informed to whats goin down in our world. To that effect, heres a few thoughts from last weekends TCP Miss Lesbian 1st runner up Sarah Beyers: Ok so once again there seems to be a debate swirling within the community concerning my eligibility & subsequent competition & RI Pride’s Miss Lesbian RI pageant. Sound familiar? Yes, we have been down this road before. As far as eligibility, well we took care of that last year. As noted in a public release statement from RI Pride LAST March, here it is: This year, a number of individuals have asked for clarification as to the eligibility of transgender people participating in the RI Pride Triple Crown Pageant. As our community continues to grow and expand, RI Pride endeavors to fulfill its mission to provide safe opportunities for people to come out, express and celebrate their sexual identities.
To that end, as an organization we strive to work on being inclusive in our policies recognizing that at times our decisions might not be in harmony with the thinking of some in our community.
So the question, can a transgender individual run in the categories of Miss Gay, Ms. Lesbian or Mr. Gay RI? The answer is yes. Since the person who publicly self-identifies as such, we would allow the contestant in said category.
To further understand where Rhode Island stands in regards to public policy and the law in reference to gender identity and expression, Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders states on their website: In May, 2001, Rhode Island became the second state in the country to explicitly prohibit discrimination on the basis of gender identity or expression, thereby protecting transgender people from discrimination in employment, housing, credit, and public accommodations. The law defines gender identity or expression as including a persons actual or perceived gender, as well as a persons gender identity, gender-related self image, gender-related appearance, or gender-related expression, whether or not that gender identity is different from that traditionally associated with the persons sex at birth.
As representatives of RI Pride, any titleholder is required to be open, out and to serve as a representative of the community. Clear and concise requirements are detailed in the contestant application and contract with regards to conduct, protocol, and activities for such titleholders. Titleholders recognize that this is not a part-time commitment but is a year-long, 24/7 role in which they serve and as such are constantly under public scrutiny.
All contestants will have the same opportunity to express themselves as to how they will serve the community as a titleholder through the process of private interviews with the judges on the day of the pageant.
We hope this clarification will encourage greater participation from the community at large. We understand that some will not agree with this policy and we encourage community discussion on it. However, one of Rhode Island Prides greatest strengths is the fact that we provide opportunities for self-actualization when it comes to sexual identities, recognizing that definitions about our community are fluid and are constantly evolving.”
So there you have it, Pride fully supports this endeavor. End of debate, right? Not really, seems there is still much talk about this within the community. As far as I’m concerned the issue of who is “allowed” to be a Lesbian is a closed one. It’s this simple: NOBODY can tell us WHO we can be and I think Prides transgender-inclusion statement stands by this. I think the bigger question lingering is WHO won that pageant Sunday? 1st, let me say I think the judges were wonderful people. The fact that I won the interview (the highest amount of points of the whole competition) shows their ability to see through this issue and understanding & acceptance. A far as the rest of the competition..well, most of you were there so I’ll let YOU be the judge. I did have a conversation with a prominent drag-queen friend previous to the TCP and asked “her” opinion. What stuck out to me was when she said “well, you were fabulous & all but poetry is huge right now!”. All I can do is lol at that statement! Which seems to me like a thinly veiled excuse. Don’t get me wrong, I think Tara did a fine job and this is not her fault. I met her and she seems like an ambitious, sincere, sweet young girl that’s eager to be involved within the community. I think she deserves a chance and in my opinion will make a fine Miss Lesbian. I’m not bitter at the outcome nor do I dislike anyone. Theres just no time in life for these types of negative feelings. If anything else maybe some understanding and positive debate will come out of all this. Since last Sunday many people have approached me and asked if I was unhappy with RI Pride and would not support that organization etc. The answer is no. While I do feel the organization needs to re-evaluate their understanding of where trans men & women fit in this community, I do believe in the fundamental idea and mission of Pride. To polarize a community was NOT my intent, in fact just the opposite. I will say though on a personal level and as a woman I’v realized that there are “many” ways to make a difference in this world and I hope to embrace this by reaching out to non profits not only within the GLBT community but beyond. As far as the GLBT community itself, of course I still love it. I’ll continue to work with my favorite clubs & non-profits as time allows. With several part time jobs at local clubs I couldn’t leave this community even if I tried, lol. I’ll also try to spend as much time as possible within the Lesbian segment of our group. Getting back to the TCP debate, it’s interesting that the support from the ladies has come much easier then the support from others. I think it’s because they “get it” and realize theres so much more to being a woman. It comes from “inside”. Girls, you know exactly what I mean : ) Sarah
